By Felicia Barnett, Dr. Kipp Rogers, and Angela Seiders - Principals, NNPS
My deadline was when? How many of us have forgotten deadlines and received extensions and second chances from our bosses? When you forgot to turn in something, did your boss call and tell you that you couldn’t do it because it was too late? No, in all likelihood, you had additional time to complete the task. If you forget to pay your electric bill, does the electric company tell you that you can’t pay it and shut off our electricity? No, they grant you an extension, sometimes multiple extensions. So why, as educators, are we so reluctant to give kids a second chance? Give that zero! Shouldn’t our objective be to help students succeed?
Real situation: Middle school student struggles in Spanish class. Mom hires a tutor for the class. Student is doing better. Student is nervous about taking the test. He takes the test. Realizes a few minutes after giving the test to the teacher he thinks he missed a page. He asks teacher if he could have the test back because he thinks he missed a page. Teacher tells student, “No, you did miss the page, and you can’t have it back.” Student gets a D on the test. Mom has to email the teacher about the test. Teacher tells the parent he can’t retake it. Mom calls the assistant principal for help. Luckily, assistant principal decides to let student retake the test. What message did we send to this student? Is all this really necessary? What about the student that has no one to call on his behalf? I guess that student would have failed.
For 21st Century Learners it is so it is easy to take a zero. The student gets out of doing work, and the teacher doesn’t have to grade it. WOW! Getting a zero makes everyone’s life so easy. Is that the message we want to send to our students? If Harvard University and Yale give students the Power of the I- why isn’t it good enough for our students?
Knowing that students who struggle in the classroom and fall behind academically are more likely to drop out of school in the future, many schools are testing a policy in which students would receive an “I” (incomplete) for work that was not turned in or did not meet the standards. The idea is to give students extra time and extra help to improve their achievement.
The success of the Power of the I stems from faculty buy-in. Most schools have teachers pilot the program and then report out the results. The entire faculty would need to understand the rationale and full implementation. Obviously, educators would need administrative support for the change.
Once a student receives an “I” on a report card, they have two weeks from the end of the grading period to be retaught and to redo the work. If the student does not redo the work, the grade defaults to a “D” or an “F”.
Schools that provide a pyramid of interventions to assist its students in meeting standards are most successful with the Power of the I.
Some school wide interventions are as follows:
•Teachers post missing assignments in the classroom or on www.engrade.com so students will know what they need to complete. The assignments are posted by student ID number, rather than by name, to ensure anonymity.
•Schools provide an after- school tutoring program. The schedule is posted online for students and parents will know when and where help is available.
•School leaders and teachers talk individually with students who are falling behind. Students seriously at risk in failing must meet with an audit team consisting of the principal, the guidance counselor, and a teacher. Team members use an intervention tracking sheet to guide the discussion and to formulate a plan of action for the student.
The effectiveness of the Power of the I policy obviously increases student performance if implemented correctly. The importance of the Power of the I grading policy is in helping students meet standards and not allowing students to settle for a zero or an F. The whole purpose is to help students learn and to hold them accountable for their own learning. At the end of the day, isn’t that why we all became educators?